Jump to content

Should I take protein powder?


Jessica.veggiegirl
 Share

Recommended Posts

My name is Jessica. I was a vegetarian for 13 years and i have been a vegan for a little over 1 year. After i became vegan i started working out a lot and i go to the gym almost 2 hours pretty much everyday. I have made a lot of improvements at the gym and am doing really well. My goal is to get a lot more muscular and toned and get the bottom of my six pack to come through (need to lose a teeny bit of fat still). My boyfriend, who has been working out for the past 3 years, told me i should take protein powder because it will help boost my improvements and will be good for helping maintain my muscle as well. I know he is right and it sounds like a great idea but i can't help feeling very torn about taking it. I am very healthy and despite never monitering or worrying about protein intake have gained a lot of muscle and strength improvements. I worry that if i take protein powder, if people know, they will act like because i am a vegan i HAVE to take it for my muscle. Almost anyone who tries to gain a lot of muscle takes it but people can be so ignorant and i am always asked about protein and if tofu is the only thing i can get protein from (i never even eat tofu or fake meats) I really want to take the powder and get a good boost and be able to put some extra focus on my weight loss and treadmill with out having to worry too much about muscle loss but i am worried that people will act as if without it i would not be able to get enough protein as a vegan. I need some advice because i really feel torn about this. Thank you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

People are always concerned when they find out I am vegan and want to make sure I am in top notch health. Try some different proteins and find what works best for you and just focus on you not what everyone else is thinking. Once they see that you can do it they will support you

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes I know i shouldn't let other people effect what i do for myself but the idea of an unhealthy and overweight person acting as if i get all of my protein from a drink is keeping me from it lol. I am really thinking i am going to do it. i am doing fine without it but everyone does it to build muscle and it is supposed to give a boost so i should probably give it a go.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"Getting enough protein" depends on what you're doing and what your goals are. Just for everyday life, health and avoiding protein-deficiency is simple and you don't even need to worry about it, but for bodybuilding it's a whole different matter.

 

I can get plenty of protein for everyday life on a vegan diet, you don't really need very much, and to start with (before I knew anything about bodybuilding) I consumed that much whilst trying to increase muscle mass. I was eating about 65g of protein a day. That is easy to get, in fact I'd say it's hard not to (so long as you are eating the usual things like bread, pasta , rice...) I made progress even on that small amount, and became fit and lean. However I didn't get very big

 

But after I read anything about building muscle, I realised I'd need more, and that's where the powder comes in handy because you can boost the protein without the carbs or fat that food would give you. Almost all bodybuilders use some kind of protein supplement - vegan or not.

 

People ask me "Oh, you take a protein drink... because you're vegan" (as though that's the only way a vegan can get any, like it's cheating) and I say "No, I take it because I lift weights"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you for the advice. I have made a lot of progress with out worrying about my protein at all but my end goals do involve getting a lot of muscle so i decided to start. I was worried that if people knew they would say things like that "oh you have to because you are vegan." I will definetely use what you said Robert thank you for that! but I decided i am just not going to tell anyone untill I look a bit more muscular.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess it depends why you're doing it. If you think it's important to put across the message that you can achieve what you've done without protein supplements, then that's what you'll have to do. But I think you should consider why that is. Is it just because of what other people will think - even if they are wrong to think it? Sometimes I consider dropping protein supplements altogether because I'd rather eat a more "natural" diet (as far as is possible), for my own health, and for some kind of feeling of "doing it right" or not cheating...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well i definetely do not think it is cheating because cheating is giving yourself an unfair advantage over others and every body builder or person trying to build a lot of muscle takes protein powder. I just don't want people to think i have to take protein shakes because i am a vegan and i do have a decent amount of muscle but i am not muscular enough yet to feel confident about saying i do this because i lift weights and build lots of muscle etc. etc. My plan for now is to continue working out as i am because i am getting really good results and take the protien powder. After i am more muscular i will let people know. My boyfriend keeps telling me not to worry about what others think about it but i get really pissed off when people act like my diet isn't good. I have the reputation as a health police with everyone who knows me so i get very little of people trying to say my diet is bad, generally people defend their diet to me so having ignorant fat people ask about protein might make me say something nasty hehe.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why is it so important what other people are thinking? Does an omnivore bodybuilder have thoughts about "cheating" when taking protein powders? And even if people are thinking vegans do have to take protein shakes to get enough protein... I couldn't care any less. I explain it to them (the whole weight lifting thing) and if they get it, it's fine. If not, they're obviously not able to get a very simple thing into their brains.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd prefer taking in my protein without powders, however, I noticed two things:

 

1) My calorie count is too high when taking in 2 g of protein per kg of lean body mass without protein powders

 

2) Omnivores often seem to face the same dilemma or they eat a diet so full of lean meat they're barely able to look at it anymore

 

Protein powders enable both vegans and omnivores to relax a bit about protein intake and planning. I'm convinced it would be healthier to eat all natural foods but I admit that I'm not able to be consistent with that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I take protein powders to keep increasing my muscle size faster. I was eating a decent vegan diet (about 3000 calories, 65 grams of protein), and hitting the weights really heavy. But I noticed that I would be sore the next day from the bodypart that I worked out, and the next, and the next. In fact, it would take a good week for the worked bodypart to feel normal again. When I added the protein powder to my diet (in between the meals), I would work the bodypart heavy once again, and be sore the next day, but the day after that it would get less sore, and it was already on the third day that it would be feeling normal again. So in my case, it speed up the time of recovery for me. So I can go without it, but why would I when I can repair my muscles faster? And it really is faster for the bigger bodyparts: legs, back, and chest - perhaps the shoulders too in my case.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 year later...

Hey . i do think it has helped me. I have gained a lot of muscle since this thread started haha. I usually take about 2 scoops a day when i go to the gym. before and after my work out and i also somtimes drink a protein banana spinach smoothie for breakfast instead of my usual oatmeal. I do think they are a great and stressfree way to keep protein intake up when working out, i definetely recommend it for those trying to build lots of muscle, i'm really glad i decided to take it =).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Welcome to the community here Jessica. I'll jump in with my 2 cents and agree with what most everyone is saying. Protein powders are a crazy fad right now and everyone seems to think they need to be taking them. Even the meat eaters out there seem to be wolfing them down. If you are trying to build seriously they can be helpful but don't fall into the marketing scheme that you need them just because you are working out and want to get fit.

 

-Dylan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ya, if i wasn't really trying to build muscle i wouldn't bother with them. I never had any problems getting protein before as a vegan or vegetarian but they are a nice low calorie and convenient way for me to get a nice protein boost and i work out almost purely for vanity so it does help to be able to get a high amount of protein to support muscle growth while not consuming too many calories. X)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ya, if i wasn't really trying to build muscle i wouldn't bother with them. I never had any problems getting protein before as a vegan or vegetarian but they are a nice low calorie and convenient way for me to get a nice protein boost and i work out almost purely for vanity so it does help to be able to get a high amount of protein to support muscle growth while not consuming too many calories. X)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...