Trap Bar Deadlift vs Barbell Deadlift For Gaining Mass?

Share your training programs, favorite exercises, training secrets and tips with the rest of the group. Discuss contest preparation, off-season diets, carb depleting and loading, posing, and training programs.

Moderators: Mini Forklift Ⓥ, C.O., Richard, robert, SyrLinus

Message
Author
User avatar
Arion
Rabbit
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Feb 11, 2011 11:21 pm
Location: Maui Hawaii

Trap Bar Deadlift vs Barbell Deadlift For Gaining Mass?

#1 Postby Arion » Fri Mar 25, 2011 9:06 pm

Any thoughts?


Trap Bar Deadlift
Image

Barbell Deadlift
Image

User avatar
bronco
Gorilla
Posts: 638
Joined: Sat Sep 03, 2005 12:51 pm
Location: Vienna, Austria
Contact:

Re: Trap Bar Deadlift vs Barbell Deadlift For Gaining Mass?

#2 Postby bronco » Sat Mar 26, 2011 3:22 am

Trap bar allows a slightly more upright torso so could use slightly more legs and slightly less back. However I think the difference is insignificant enough that you should do whatever feels more comfortable.

User avatar
chrisjs
Elephant
Posts: 1228
Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:41 pm
Location: Piscataway, NJ, US

Re: Trap Bar Deadlift vs Barbell Deadlift For Gaining Mass?

#3 Postby chrisjs » Sat Mar 26, 2011 8:41 am

I think you're really splitting hairs here. More focus on legs with the trap bar, like bronco said. If you're really worried, do both!

User avatar
Arion
Rabbit
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Feb 11, 2011 11:21 pm
Location: Maui Hawaii

Re: Trap Bar Deadlift vs Barbell Deadlift For Gaining Mass?

#4 Postby Arion » Sat Mar 26, 2011 3:58 pm

Thanks guys!

Stuart McRobert author of Brawn comments caught my attention below. Particularly in relation to hardgainers.

History : Invented by Al Gerard, a deadlift record holder in ADFPA (US drug free powerlifting) - Deadlifting 625 lbs at a bodyweight of 205 lbs, and past age 40. The Trap Bar solved his way to training without aggravating old lower back injuries.

Gerard found that the Trap Bar could work his legs and hips extremely well, without aggravating his fragile back. In fact, his Trap Bar training replaced the Back Squat most of the year, even though he competed in powerlfting. He found he could squat 500lbs despite only training in the squat a couple months a year - the Trap Bar kept his legs strong.

The Trap bar has been championed by Hardgainer Magazine, Cyberpump, Bob Whelan's Natural Strength, Paul Kelso and Dr Ken Leistner.

Deadlift or Squat or "Squatlift"? : It's basically a hybrid of the deadlift and the squat. Very similar to doing squats with dumbells, except you can load up far heavier weights. It's a brilliant alternative to the Squat and regular barbell deadlift. Most people find the parallel grip very comfortable. On high rep sets, it can tilt backwards and forwards, but you can solve that with lifting straps. Although, obviously, it's gives your grip less of a workout.

Stuart McRobert says in Beyond Brawn "Do not consider the Trap Bar deadlift as just an alternative to the barbell squat. It is an outstanding exercise in it's own right....The Trap Bar deadlift is the equal of the squat for many hardgainers...In fact, it has the potential to be the number one productive exercise for many hard gainers"

How it works: Because you stand in it, rather than behind it - you can lower yourself down whilst keeping you back straight - rather than tilting forward like in the barbell squat and deadlift.

Again, I'll quote McRobert : "In any type of bent-legged deadlift with a Trap Bar there are some big advantages relative to the squat:

1. The Bar is held beneath the body rather than precariously near the top of the spine as in the squat, and thus there is no bar bearing down on you.
2. Good form is easier to maintain because the deadlift is technically less demanding than the squat
3. Spotters are not needed
4. No squat stands, power rack or safety bars are needed
5. The exercise is easily done from a dead stop at the bottom."
For home trainers it's by far the safest way to lift real heavy.

Trap Bar Exercises:

• Bent legged deadlift aka Squatlift - the main exercise as detailed above
• Stiff Legged deadlift
• Parallel grip upright rows
• Parallel grip high pulls
• Shrugs - Olympic lifter's staple - Paul Kelso has written a whole book about them.
• Farmers walk - load up and walk as far as you can. A 'finisher' as popularised by Dinosaur Training.
• You can even do overhead presses but will need to improvise some kind of rack to get it up to shoulder height.

User avatar
VeganEssentials
Stegosaurus
Posts: 3065
Age: 42
Joined: Wed Dec 31, 1969 7:00 pm
Location: Waukesha, WI
Contact:

Re: Trap Bar Deadlift vs Barbell Deadlift For Gaining Mass?

#5 Postby VeganEssentials » Mon Mar 28, 2011 1:25 am

One thing to note, while a trap bar CAN be easier on the lower back for some, it isn't necessarily guaranteeing it can't aggravate things. One of my nastiest lower back tweaks from my injured spot came from doing a farmer's handle deadlift, pretty much a trap-bar style lift, just with two separate handles held at the sides. In theory, it SHOULD have been easier on my lower back, but I still spent 3 weeks screaming every time I had to sit down or stand up :cry:

A decent device, but one thing's for sure, it's just one tool in the arsenal. Nothing wrong with using a trap bar, but for some, the carryover won't be much since it will definitely feel different as soon as you change back to a barbell!
"A 'hardgainer' is merely someone who hasn't bothered to try enough different training methods to learn what is actually right for their own damned body." - anonymous


Return to “Bodybuilding/Strength Training”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests